“We know that many municipal bond credit ratings are no longer accurate because they are based on the downgraded rating of the bond insurer, not of the municipal issuer. So we are stepping in to make sure that insurance companies have accurate ratings. The SVO has the tools to fairly rate municipal issuers,” said Wisconsin Insurance Commissioner Sean Dilweg, who made the proposal.
“Removing the current restrictions on our rating unit will permit insurance companies to submit downgraded municipal securities to it. The unit, where appropriate, will now be able to assign the correct rating to those municipal bonds. That will benefit both insurance companies and municipal issuers,” said New York State Insurance Superintendent Eric Dinallo, who chairs the NAIC Valuation of Securities Task Force.
Currently, when a bond insurer is downgraded, the municipal bonds it insures receive the same lower rating. That lower rating can result in the new rating for the bond being below the actual creditworthiness of the municipal issuer.
The downgrading of bonds they hold can create problems for insurance companies. At a minimum, companies would have to reserve more capital against the downgraded bonds, because reserves are determined by the risk of the investment. That reduces their appetite for municipal bonds. If bonds are downgraded to below investment grade, some insurance companies will no longer want to hold them. If many companies sell downgraded bonds, they would likely push down the market price and have to take a loss on the bonds. This could also increase municipalities’ cost of raising funds.
To avoid these problems, insurance company investors will be allowed to submit their municipal bonds to the SVO for credit assessment. Previously, the SVO was not permitted to assign a credit rating higher than that assigned by a rating agency. The new procedure would allow the SVO to determine its own rating based on its own analysis of the issuer’s financial strength.
This amendment to the Purposes and Procedures Manual of the NAIC Securities Valuation Office will be effective July 1, 2008. The NAIC will continue to use the resources of the SVO to assist regulators in dealing with disruptions in the capital markets.
The change is part of a three-pronged regulatory response to recent concerns about the bond insurance market that (1) addresses the continued availability of AAA-rated bond insurance for municipalities; (2) deals with distressed companies by working to bolster contingency reserves; and (3) considers new and/or revised rules and regulations.