Antone Costa Rita, Jr., 58, was apprehended on July 31 at his residence as the result of an investigation conducted by the California Department of Insurance (CDI). He was charged with presenting a false or fraudulent insurance claim and making false or fraudulent statements to his employer and to his treating physicians.
On Nov 19, 2002, Rita filed a workers' comp insurance claim with his employer, the City of Menlo Park, alleging that on Oct 24, 2002 he "rolled" his left ankle while painting lines at a tennis court in a city-owned park.
Over a five-year period ending Oct 24, 2007, Rita told his treating and evaluating doctors that he was unemployed, that his injury continued to worsen, and that he either could not walk or walked with great difficulty, pain and limping, even after having surgery to repair the injury. Rita also made similar statements while under oath to an attorney representing Menlo Park during a Nov 16, 2005, deposition.
However, undercover surveillance videotape taken on various dates throughout 2006 by a private investigation firm for Menlo Park captured Rita walking normally and bearing weight on his left ankle with no indications of pain. The private investigation firm also videoed Rita involved in activities that appeared to be work-related at a San Jose auto repair shop.
CDI's investigation revealed that Rita made inconsistent statements and material misrepresentations regarding the severity of his industrial injury and his employment status during appointments with physicians treating and/or evaluating him. CDI also found these inconsistencies in Rita's sworn testimony while under oath in a deposition for the purpose of filing a false workers' compensation insurance claim with, and receiving reparation from, Menlo Park via the city's third party administrator (TPA), Innovative Claims Solutions (ICS).
The alleged fraud cost Menlo Park, via its TPA, nearly $170,000. As a result of Rita's material misrepresentations, ICS paid out more than $38,200 in indemnity benefits, $23,300 in temporary total disability benefits, $14,800 in permanent disability benefits, $38,500 in medical treatment, $3,600 in vocational rehabilitation benefits, and $50,400 in legal expenses, including defense costs and surveillance/investigation.